The last 12 months have been transformational for DeFi. The sector grew by triple-digit rates by almost every adoption metric. However, some notable headwinds ranging from regulatory concerns to infrastructural limitations transformed the initial excitement into a somewhat disappointing year for investors.
But skeptics beware. Like many disruptive technologies, DeFi has been propelled by new waves of adoption, which have been emerging every couple of years. And the challenges that have negatively impacted prices in the near term could be the catalysts that set in motion the next major wave for DeFi.
The first wave of DeFi introduced novel use cases for programmable money, like MakerDAO’s decentralized stablecoin DAI and Bancor’s Automated Market Maker (which has been working better than the traditional order book system for some trading applications). But in 2017 DeFi was brand new, and usage of these applications was relatively niche.
The second wave began with the “DeFi Summer” of 2020. Entrepreneurs and developers empowered by DeFi’s earlier developments explored new corners of what was possible in a decentralized and composable financial world. They introduced other financial primitives to DeFi like governance tokens, user incentives, and decentralized insurance and asset management applications.
These innovations brought increasing user stickiness and capital retention, from users and developers to capital deployed (TVL) and monthly revenue. Not to mention the stark improvement we’ve seen in the stability of protocols and stablecoins during times of extreme volatility.
DeFi’s Adoption Metrics Soared in 2021, Despite Disappointing Price Performance
Evolution of select industry adoption metrics in 2021 over 2020
Yet regulatory and scaling limitations arose in 2021 and prevented DeFi from achieving the escape velocity that market participants and investors had hoped for. Instead, interest shifted towards newer market segments, like NFTs and high-throughput blockchains, both of which delivered outstanding returns.
However, there’s a new transition currently taking place.
As a testament to the adage that the seeds of the next market cycle are sown in the challenges of the last, we are now seeing the first inklings of the third adoption wave. Developers and entrepreneurs have already been working feverishly on overcoming the obstacles mentioned above.
In our view, the following three trends are leading the way to bring about the third adoption wave in DeFi:
#1: Congestion and Extremely High Gas Fees
DeFi fell victim to its success in 2021: The explosive adoption the industry experienced led to massive network congestion and exorbitant transaction fees. Today, for instance, it costs more than $50 to execute a trade on the Ethereum network, making DeFi activities impractical for many users. A core promise of DeFi is to make financial transactions cheaper and more efficient, and high gas fees render that concept ironically moot.
Unlike inflation, however, this pain is likely to be transitory; one of the biggest stories in DeFi last year was the market responding to this challenge with massive innovation. Specifically, the rollout of Ethereum scaling solutions such as Arbitrum and Optimism—and the growth of high-throughput blockchains like Avalanche and Solana—have created new and cheaper rails for DeFi to operate on.
Ethereum Scaling Solutions Offer Fast and Low-Cost Alternatives
The token swap fee is the transaction cost associated with a token exchange.
Users and capital are already migrating to these solutions, which provide higher-speed transactions at a fraction of the historical costs. Previously priced-out users who want to trade a hundred dollars’ worth of crypto on Uniswap can now do so without paying the equivalent in fees. More importantly, developers who have ideas that are economically interesting with $1 transaction fees—but not $50 transaction fees—can now push those forward.
This cadence—development, congestion, further development, and so on—is a well-documented pattern in crypto called the application-infrastructure cycle. In this cycle, a surge in the usage of crypto applications leads to an infrastructure phase focused on building new platforms and products. This, in turn, leads to a rise in usage and broader consumer adoption, which funds the next wave of development, and so on.
With these scaling solutions now up and running at full speed, DeFi is getting closer to achieving its goal of bringing a more accessible and efficient financial system to a much broader public. This is critical in bringing the next 100 million users into DeFi and creating space for new financial innovations.
#2: Regulation and Permissioned DeFi
DeFi represents a fundamental challenge to many of the core building blocks of the existing financial regulatory structure. As a result, leading regulatory agencies have sometimes taken an opposing view towards DeFi protocols.
The regulatory pressure dialed up significantly in 2021 when the SEC threatened regulatory action against DeFi protocols that “operate outside of the perimeter” and made clear that DeFi protocols are “not immune to regulation.” There was also talk of aggressive regulation of stablecoins, protocols that facilitate the trading of synthetic derivatives, and more. These weighed on the market and impacted prices—financial advisors cited “regulatory uncertainty” as the #1 factor preventing them from allocating to crypto in client accounts.
One response to this trend is the rise of so-called “permissioned” DeFi, a layer built on top of existing DeFi applications designed to meet standard regulatory burdens by only allowing a subset of whitelisted users to participate. In June, Compound launched a compliance-friendly version of their protocol for businesses and financial institutions, called Compound Treasury. Meanwhile, Aave launched a similar product called Aave Arc, which went live recently with 30 financial institutions whitelisted by the crypto custodian Fireblocks.
Permissioned DeFi is poised to take off in 2022, much earlier than it would have without regulatory pressure. If it continues to gain traction, it can bring institutional-scale capital into the DeFi market in a meaningful way.
#3: The DeFi-ification of Everything
The last big story from 2021 that will impact DeFi’s trajectory in 2022 was the massive expansion of crypto’s surface area into the realm of NFTs, gaming, DAOs, the Metaverse, and other verticals.
For nearly all of these, DeFi acts as the financial backbone in one way or another.
For example, crypto gaming relies on DeFi to facilitate in-game activities like trading. At the same time, play-to-earn crypto games like DeFi Kingdoms combine gamification concepts with things like liquidity providing and yield farming, creating a funnel of assets into the DeFi ecosystem.
Similarly, services like NFTfi’s marketplace for NFT-collateralized loans enable borrowing against idiosyncratic assets, while DAOs turn to DeFi protocols for liquidity providing and lending to make markets for their governance tokens and generate yield on the assets held by their treasuries.
The growth and stickiness of new crypto verticals have a powerful amplifying effect on the expansion of DeFi. As the surface area of DeFi gets larger, the revenue generated by DeFi applications increases, and their ability to invest in future growth accelerates.
This third wave of adoption is likely to be the biggest one yet. After all, it’s still early days in DeFi. The 4.3 million DeFi users are the same number of users that the internet logged in 1991, and the $150 billion DeFi market cap is less than 1% of the $24 trillion legacy finance market.
This is not to say that DeFi does not have risks, of course. Regulatory clarity could get worse before improving, the possibility of technical or economic exploits will likely continue to loom large over many protocols, and new challenges are likely to arise.
But while it is impossible to know whether DeFi prices have already bottomed, especially in the uncertain current macroeconomic environment, the seeds of DeFi’s future success are now being sown. The hurdles from 2021 now look more like stepping stones than roadblocks.
Based in San Francisco, Bitwise is one of the largest and fastest-growing crypto asset managers, offering both index and active strategies across a wide array of investment vehicles. The firm is known for creating the world’s largest crypto index fund (OTCQX: BITW), a suite of crypto-focused equity and futures ETFs, and investment products that span Bitcoin, Ethereum, DeFi, NFTs, and the Metaverse. Bitwise focuses on partnering with financial advisors and investment professionals to provide quality education and research. The team at Bitwise combines expertise in technology with decades of experience in traditional asset management and indexing, coming from firms including BlackRock, Blackstone, Meta, and Google, as well as the U.S. Attorney’s Office. Bitwise is backed by leading institutional investors and asset management executives, and has been profiled in Institutional Investor, CNBC, Barron’s, Bloomberg, and The Wall Street Journal.