Bitwise Crypto Index Committee Meeting
August 6, 2020
Meeting called to discuss 51% attacks on Ethereum Classic.
Bitwise Crypto Index Committee Meeting
August 6, 2020
2:00 – 2:30 P.M. PT
Reason for Meeting:
Matt Hougan (Chair), Hunter Horsley (Member), David Lawant (Member), Hong Kim (Observer)
Item 1: Ethereum Classic’s 51% Attacks
The Chair of the Bitwise Crypto Index Committee called an emergency meeting to discuss the unfolding situation surrounding Ethereum Classic (ETC). ETC is a cryptoasset that is held in the Bitwise 20 Mid Cap Crypto Index, Bitwise 100 Total Market Crypto Index, and the Bitwise 10 Select Crypto Index. It recently endured two 51% attacks in a short period of time.
The Committee reviewed the following developments:
- On August 1, 2020, Ethereum Classic experienced a significant 51% attack. A miner generated a series of 3,763 blocks over many hours and then broadcast them at once to other miners. As reported by blockchain intelligence firm BitQuery, not all nodes reacted the same way: some (Geth and Hyperledger Besu) accepted the attacker blocks, but Open Ethereum did not. As a result, the blockchain was split into two versions, one of which included the attacker blocks and another which didn’t.
- Ethereum Classic developers initially stated that the attack did not seem malicious, as it could have happened because a miner had lost internet access while mining. Their recommendation at that point to other miners was to continue mining the chain as-is (i.e., work on the chain that included the blocks inserted by the attacker).
- Later on, BitQuery reported that the attacker double-spent 807,260 ETC (equivalent to $5.6 million) and estimated that the total cost of the hash power used for the attack was 17.5 BTC (equivalent to $192k). On top of that, the attacker also received roughly 13,000 ETC in block mining rewards. It is believed that the address that had the ETC drained from it belonged to OKEx.
- On August 6, 2020, the network suffered a second 51% attack. The attack was identified by exchange Binance and by crypto mining pool Bitfly. According to Coindesk, the second block reorganization was roughly 4,000 blocks long; deeper than the first one. A few minutes later, Ethereum Classic developers recommended ETC service providers to “significantly raise confirmation times on all deposit and incoming transactions.”
- As of now, the Committee could not find an estimate of the monetary value of the second attack.
- From a price action perspective, ETC was mostly rising until the August 1 attack, but it crashed from a high of $8.297 to a low of $6.393 at the end of that day (Pacific Time). Prices then quickly recovered and, as the chart shows, ETC has been trading in the roughly $7.00-$7.30 range since then.
This is not the first time Ethereum Classic has been 51% attacked. On January 7, 2019, Coinbase detected an attack that totaled $1.1M worth of reorganizations. The exchange then paused all interactions with the ETC blockchain and resumed sends and receives by March 11, 2019.
- Other media articles about the episode:
Rule III.B.i.f of the Bitwise Crypto Index Methodology states that, for a cryptoasset to be eligible for inclusion in the index, it must have “no known security vulnerabilities, including critical bugs, undue exposure to 51% attacks, or other factors, as determined by the Bitwise Crypto Index Committee.” The methodology adds that “This requirement exists to ensure the asset is not knowingly exposed to a critical security risk that could lead to a significant loss in value.”
The Committee took a vote to determine whether ETC was in violation of Rule III.B.i.f given recent developments. The Committee voted 3-0 that ETC was in violation of Rule III.B.i.f. As a result, the Committee determined it would be removed from all relevant indexes on an “emergency basis.”
Rule III.B.ii.b governs the emergency removal of assets from the Bitwise Crypto Indexes. The rule states that all removals will take place at 4pm ET following the publication of the notes of the meeting. As a result, ETC will be removed from the relevant indexes at 4pm ET on Friday, August 7, 2020.
Rule VI.B.ii.g governs the emergency removal of assets from the Bitwise Select 10 Large Cap Crypto Index. The rule states that all removals will take place at 5pm Zurich Local Time following the publication of the notes of the meeting. As a result, ETC will be removed from the relevant indexes at 5pm Zurich Local Time on Monday, August 10, 2020.
Per the rules of the index, the value currently allocated to ETC will be redistributed to other assets already present in the index. Bitwise Crypto Indexes do not replace assets removed on an emergency basis per Rule III.B.i.f until the following reconstitution event.
Item 2: Adjournment
The Chairman adjourned the meeting.
Bitwise Asset Management, Inc. and its affiliates (collectively, the “Manager”) have produced and distributes this Presentation for informational purposes only and in relation to a potential opportunity to subscribe for limited liability company interests (“Interests”) in any of several Funds offered only to certain Accredited Investors by the Manager, including the Bitwise 10 Crypto Index Fund, LLC; the Bitwise Bitcoin Fund, LLC; the Digital Asset Index Fund, LLC; the Bitwise 10 Index Offshore Fund, Ltd.; and the Bitwise Ethereum Fund, LLC. Any offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy Interests in those Funds will solely and exclusively be made through definitive offering documents, identified as such, in respect of each Fund and in compliance with the terms of all applicable securities and other laws. Such definitive offering documents, if any, will describe risks related to an investment in the Funds (including loss of the entire investment) and will qualify in their entirety the information set forth in this Presentation.
Prior to making any investment decision with respect to any Fund, each investor must undertake its own independent examination and investigation of the Fund, including the merits and risks involved in an investment in the Interests, and must base its investment decision—including a determination whether Interests would be a suitable investment for the investor—on such examination and investigation, and must not rely on the Manager or the Fund in making such investment decision. Prospective investors must not construe the contents of this Presentation as legal, tax, investment, or other advice. Each prospective investor is urged to consult with his or her own advisors with respect to legal, tax, regulatory, financial, accounting, and similar consequences of investing in the Fund, the suitability of the investment for such investor, and other relevant matters concerning an investment in the Fund. The summary set forth in this Presentation does not purport to be complete and is qualified in its entirety by reference to the definitive offering documents relating to the Fund. Do not place undue reliance on this Presentation. Performance information is provided for informational purposes only. Actual performance of any Fund may vary substantially from the performance provided in this presentation. Backward-looking performance cannot predict how any investment strategy will perform in the future. The Units of the Funds (the “Interests”) have not been registered under the Securities Act of 1933, the securities laws of any state, or the securities laws of any other jurisdiction, nor is such registration contemplated. The Interests will be offered and sold under the exemption provided by Section 4(a)(2) of the Securities Act of 1933 and Rule 506 of Regulation D promulgated thereunder and other exemptions of similar import in the laws of the states and jurisdictions where the offering will be made. The offer and sale of the Interests have not been registered with or approved or disapproved by the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) or the securities commission or regulatory authority of any state or foreign jurisdiction.